Thursday, 16 August 2007

Chapter 133

It was after 10pm by the time Harry and Danny had wrapped up their work. They had completed a dozen or so sheets of flip chart paper, which had been torn off and blu-tacked around the walls, so that the office looked like one huge family tree. In the process, they’d pulled apart a few speculations, and the scoring system had allowed them to identify the gaps they still had to fill out – hopefully, through a combination of the certificates Harry fully expected to get the next day, and the further probing of Laurel and Lillian McFry.

Danny was collecting the empty coffee cups, while Harry closed the window.

“You know, we’re going to have to lay it on the line with those two ladies, don’t you?” he asked, before Danny had disappeared to the kitchen.

“How do you mean?”

“Well, the situation with the bond has changed things, wouldn’t you say?”

Danny was concerned. He still felt a duty to protect Lillian: she was his client, and she’d made it clear she didn’t want Laurel to know about her.

“You’re not suggesting we tell Laurel about Lillian, are you?” . Harry had returned to his seat.

“I don’t see we’ve got much choice. The DNA results alone show a common paternal link between Laurel’s mother and Dacre Lawrence. She’s going to expect us to have found out about the mothers, don’t you think?”

Danny wasn’t sure. “Maybe it can wait a day or two, Harry. She doesn’t have to know tomorrow, surely?” A delay, even of a few days, might give them the chance to persuade Lillian that Laurel had a right to know about her mother’s parentage.

“Hmm … that’s true,” Harry said, scratching his chin. “But don’t forget, some of these certificates will open up a few more doors. We’re going to have to play it by ear.”

“Why don’t we see what Lillian makes of it all, first?” Danny said. “I still don’t really understand why she doesn’t want Laurel to know about her…”

Harry had given this matter some thought, and he shared it with Danny.

“Look at it this way. A young woman from Yorkshire is fighting in a Civil War in a foreign country hundreds of miles from home. She gets separated from her lover, Jonathan Harcourt, but hooks up again with one of the McFry brothers she originally traveled out there with. She gets pregnant. The baby’s born out there.”

Danny had turned back from his journey to the kitchen, had put the mugs on the corner of the desk, and taken his seat again, opposite Harry.

“And?” he asked, not sure where Harry was heading.

“The birth isn’t registered anywhere. It’s a civil war, remember. Not the kind of thing conducive to the keeping of meticulous records. Anyway … she subsequently travels with Stuart McFry and the baby, and escapes to south west France. Where she leaves Colleen. Quite a brave thing to do. But she’s planning to return for her, until the war intervenes.”

Danny was thinking about the DNA evidence.

“So where does John Lawrence fit in?”

Harry sat back in the chair. “On the surface, it looks like John Lawrence might be Jonathan Harcourt. Or at least, Harcourt might be the name Lawrence assumed as a writer for the Daily Herald. I’m sure Bill Blunt will confirm this for us. I’ll ring him tomorrow.”

Harry wondered what else Bill might have discovered. He couldn’t believe he’d have much of a story ready for that week’s Beagle, but there was the nagging worry that he’d been beavering away while Danny and he had been in Madrid. Who knows what he’d turned up?

“The way I see it, Danny, Lillian McFry’s holding back on something. And you know what? I think it’s because, at the end of the day, she didn’t know herself who the father of Colleen was.”

Harry’s comments stunned Danny. Surely a woman knew who the father of her child was – wasn’t it supposed to be, well … instinctive?

“I don’t get it. How could she not know?” he asked.

“Look at it this way. I know it’s hard to imagine, when you look at Lillian now, but she wasn’t always a geriatric. She was a beautiful woman. And in wartime, they say that ‘standards’ slip a little - you just have to think of all the wartime babies born in England when the Americans were stationed here. She probably had a lot of men running after her. We know about three or four, at least. It’s quite possible she didn’t know who fathered her child. Or that she thought it was someone other than who it really was.”

“Such as?”

Harry considered his response a moment. “Well, you yourself suspected Stuart McFry, as the prime candidate, didn’t you? What if Lillian thought the same?”

“Well, that might explain Thomas McFry’s ability to persuade Lillian to keep her secret, and to live with him as man and wife, without being married, I suppose….”

“The only thing we need to decide is who gets the pleasure of asking Lillian? She’s your client, after all…” Harry said, with a smile.

Whatever else happened, Tuesday was shaping up to be an interesting day.

Chapter 132

Once Colin McAllistair had got over the surprise of meeting a journalist who was working on a piece on the Spanish Civil War, he had a little time to think about the co-incidence while Bill Blunt was at the bar. A middle-aged couple had entered the pub while Colin and Bill had introduced themselves to each other, and the male partner was ordering their drinks ahead of Bill. When he’d been served, Colin watched him carry them across the room, the woman at his side, and they took a seat beside each other behind a small table, as far away from where Bill and he were sitting as it was possible to go.

The thought occurred to McAllistair that this Bill Blunt character could only be planning to interview Lillian McFry – unless, that was, he had another source right there in Telford, which might just add additional colour to his own planned documentary. He couldn’t be worried about the fact that a newspaper was planning a story around Lillian: in fact, he knew it could only help his chances of getting his programme off the ground. A producer would like the fact that interest, however local, had already been stimulated in a subject, and it could easily help sway their decision about whether to commission a documentary.

He looked at Bill as he was ordering the drinks, heard him ask the barmaid whether they had enough supplies of the particular whisky ‘to keep a couple of afficionados going for the evening’. He wondered what newspaper he worked for: it might be one of the nationals, but he doubted it. The man looked like he was close to retirement, and Colin felt sure he’d have come across the name Blunt if he worked for any of the London papers: he was an assiduous reader of most of them, and he varied his daily diet to the extent that no-one could have pinned him down as a Guardian reader, or a Mail man. Much later – when he learned the story of Lillian’s bond - he might have wondered whether he should have paid more attention than he invariably did to the financial pages. But, for now, he assured himself that Mr Blunt was most likely a provincial hack, even if a knowledgeable and affable one.

For his part, Bill Blunt was wondering just how many people were involved in Harry McFry’s little case. Fortuitously, he’d bumped into Cyril Galloway. Equal fortune had brought Colin McAllistair to his table tonight. He felt, instinctively, he’d have to be careful about revealing his knowledge of the Telford auctioneer. As he walked back towards Colin with the fresh drinks, he saw the couple who had taken up position on the other side of the pub. They were each of them staring fixedly ahead, and it reminded him of the (increasingly rare) evenings out he spent with his wife. He dismissed the thought as quickly as it came.

“Now, Colin. This is quite a co-incidence, wouldn’t you say?” he said, as he placed the glasses on the table and took up his seat opposite his new friend.

McAllistair picked up his own glass. “Cheers, Bill. Here’s to a successful story – for both of us! By the way, you never told me which paper you were with…”

“Oh, I’m sorry. It’s probably because I thought you wouldn’t have heard of it before. I don’t imagine the Birkenhead Beagle has many readers in London. But then, it’s only a guess that you’re from London…”

As soon as he heard the word ‘Birkenhead’, Colin’s mind was working quickly, trying to think who Bill Blunt’s source for the story might have been. Stan, who had called him up about the medals in the first place, or maybe even Harry McFry? He suspected it was more likely to be Harry.

“Well, it’s a good guess, Bill.” Maybe he could afford to show another card? “But, if you’re from Birkenhead, I imagine you’ve bumped into someone called Harry McFry in your time?”

Bill was temporarily taken aback. If McAllistair knew Harry McFry, what did this mean? Had Harry been working with him? What if he’d been maneuvering, all along, to have a TV documentary made all about his Spanish story? He needed to bottom this one out, that much was clear. And he thought he knew how to do it.

“Harry? Nobody knows him better!”

McAllistair wondered, now, just how close the journalist was to the man who’d, somehow, come into the possession of Lillian McFry’s medals, but he saw it as a chance to find out more about the man he’d met in Birkenhead, and who he had faintly recognized from somewhere, but couldn’t remember exactly where.

“Tell me about him. I met him last week, but I’m sure I came across him before,” he said.

“Harry? What’s there to tell?” Bill said. “Former university lecturer turns detective genealogist. Probably a mid-life crisis thing.”

Just the word ‘university’ was enough of a trigger…

“Of course!” Colin said, It was like a lightbulb had exploded in his head. “I knew that name was familiar! I met Harry McFry for what I thought was the first time last week, but I knew there was something familiar about him. I felt I’d met him before somewhere - I just couldn’t remember where from. It was Paris. He was at a conference I was at. Must have been five years or so ago.” Colin was relaxing. The knowledge that Harry McFry was known to him, plus the effect of the second whisky, of course, were having their effect. So – McFry was a fellow social historian. Now there was a turn up for the books: but he kicked himself for not realizing earlier how he’d known him.

“Well,” Bill said, “he’s been around the block a few times, has our Harry. I’ve covered a couple of cases he’s worked on. Always good for a story.” Bill, too, was starting to feel they might be on common ground, that he could make an ally of McAllistair, and that it might well be to their mutual benefit.

Within the space of the next hour, he learned everything Colin McAllistair knew about Jonathan Harcourt, Lillian Blyth and the medals. Confession is good for the soul, or so they say, and by the time the barmaid had opened the third bottle of whisky, Colin had also revealed the shameful role he had played in the distasteful disposal of Jonathan Harcourt’s medals all those years ago.

“We’ve all done things in our yout that we aren’t proud of,” Bill said, when he’d heard Colin’s story. “Why, there are things about my past I’d be reluctant to see on the front page of a tabloid. I have to say, though, that I suspect your Mr Galloway might have done rather well out of the affair.” He paused a moment, considering how much he should reveal to his companion. In the end, he resolved he could reveal more than he had initially intended. “I had the dubious pleasure of meeting your Mr Galloway just last week,” he said. “I suspect he’d go to any lengths to get his hands on Lillian’s medals.”

Colin shook his head. “There’s something with the medals that he seems far more interested in. I don’t know what it is, but it’s a piece of paper that he seems to think was in the box the medals were in. But, when I saw the medals there was no box. Harry just stuffed them in his pocket. Tell me – is Harry really not related at all to Lillian?”

The question was unexpected, but it had been something that had been sitting at the back of McAllistair’s mind ever since Harry had denied the fact when they’d met at Stan’shop.

Bill thought it was an interesting question, even though he knew full well that there was no link. “I doubt very much he is,” he replied. “Those McFry’s are a mixed up family, but I think I would have known if he was related to this particular branch.” He was considering the new information he’d gleaned since meeting McAllistair, who was clearly less used to the effects of whisky than a seasoned journalist like himself. It had been cheap at the price. Butit was time to up the ante a little – see what else, exactly, McAllistair knew.

“What did Harry tell you about Laurel McFry?” he asked, as innocently as he could.

Laurel? I’m afraid I don’t know anything about a Laurel McFry. Why?”

“Oh – probably my mistake,” Bill said. He began to suspect, from that moment, that Harry McFry might be working on two, parallel cases, and it irked him that he had only just worked this out. That piece of paper McAllistair had mentioned was obviously the key to unraveling yet more of the story. For now, however, he had to engineer a meeting with Lilian…

“This Lillian Blyth – or McFry – sounds like an intriguing woman, Colin. When did you say you’re meeting her?”

“Tomorrow morning. It’s just an initial interview. I still have to persuade the producers that there’s a programme worth making.”

Bill saw his opportunity, and pounced. “Well, perhaps a well-timed article in the Beagle might just add some grist to the mill?”

“Mr Blunt – you are speaking my language!” Colin exclaimed. He’d been wondering how he might suggest the same thing to his new-found friend, without seeming to be pushy.

“Then perhaps I could accompany you when you visit Lillian?”

“That would be very helpful. I’m sure she wouldn’t mind.” So far as Colin McAllistair was concerned, Lillian McFry wouldn’t have much choice in the matter. The whisky had made up his mind for him.

Bill had one final tack to explore. “Superb! But I actually came down here tonight to see if I could meet up with Galloway tomorrow,” Bill said. “He’s not returning my calls. Any idea where he is?”

“Not the faintest. And I don’t care if I never see him again,” Colin said. Sometimes, we never realize quite how prophetic the words we say might be.

Chapter 131

Shaking the tree: the patient analysis of every bit of information they’d gleaned so far. When Danny returned to the office to refill the machine with a fresh jug of water, Harry was already standing by the flip-chart, pen in hand, poised to start work. He looked every inch the college lecturer he had once been, his stance natural an relaxed.

“We’ve got to pick everything apart – and I mean everything! You OK for the rest of the night?”

Danny nodded, even if he wasn’t sure his definition of ‘the rest of the night’ co-incided with that of a man who seemed to exist on no sleep. He hoped it might mean just a couple of hours or so.

“Let’s start at the top. James and Amelia McFry.” He wrote their names on the chart. “Remind me…”

Danny got his drift, and searched through his notes.

“From the 1881 Census. You yourself said you had a note of them from your own studies into the McFry’s. And your friend, Julian, confirmed he’d seen the same record.”

“Hmmm… well, I’ll give it a ‘1’, I guess.” Harry scribbled the number next to their names, and circled it.

“What’s a ‘1’?” Danny asked – a look of puzzlement on his face.

“It’s the lowest possible score. We have one piece of information about this couple – a census record from 1881. We don’t even know if they were married.”

“But what’s this score all about?”

“You’ll see. It’s all about information. Sources. Now,” Harry said, warming to his theme. “Didn’t Laurel tell us, or at least you – that she had a marriage for a James McFry and an Anne Lawrence?

Danny turned a couple of pages in his pad. “Yes – that’s right.”

“Well, I’ve asked my contact at the GRO to look into that one. I’m not happy with this Amelia / Anne problem. We were stupid – we should have got that marriage certificate last week. Still, we might just get it tomorrow, all being well.” Harry looked disgusted with himself, Danny thought - but couldn’t work out why. Not much point beating themselves up about something that could be resolved with the help of Harry’s shady contact at the General Records Office, surely? But Harry wanted to move on, the tip of his marker pen resting on the chart.

“You also said, I think, that Laurel mentioned a younger brother of Anne Lawrence: John James. But you didn’t find them together in a census – is that right?”

Danny nodded, as Harry stepped across to briefly study his own notes. ”Hmm … not really a problem if he’s the younger brother. We might get them on the 1911 Census if we made an application.” Only a matter of months earlier, the Government had begun to accept applications for details from that particular census under the Freedom of Information Act, but it required knowledge of the address of the people you were looking for, and the process was a lengthy one.

“We might know a bit more tomorrow from the certificates, but I’ll add John James to the chart for now.” Harry drew a line above Amelia / Anne, which branched off to show her brother. “We’ll come back to these Lawrences later… but he gets no score at the moment.” He paused a second, reaching for a draught of coffee, then wiping his lips with the back of his wrist. The room was getting cold, with the window open, but at least some of the smoke had cleared.

“OK. So far, so good. I’m happier with the McFry children. Give me the details.” He watched as Danny turned more pages in his pad. He knew he’d been right to take the boy under his wing, could see his potential as a future, seasoned, genealogist. Whatever the outcome of this case, he could see himself working with Danny Longhurst again.

Danny reeled off the McFry brother’s birth details, and watched as Harry charted them up.

“Much better,” Harry said. “These all deserve a ‘2’, at least, don’t you think?”

Danny had worked out, by now, how Harry’s system worked. Each person was allocated a score, based on how much primary information they’d collected about them. They had the birth certificates for Stuart (1908), Thomas (1911) and Philip (1924). Harry was warming to the task in hand. “In fact, we’ve got some additional details that might make us up the score a little…”

But Danny was thinking about the gap between Thomas and Philip. Thirteen years was a long time – if his own parents had followed that pattern, he would have had a kid brother who was just six years old. As it was, he’d got used to being an ‘only child’, and couldn’t really imagine what it would be like to have had a sibling. Even if the experience of a few days with Harry and his brother had shown him some of the disadvantages that might accrue.

“Don’t you agree?” Harry’s question drew Danny back on track.

“Meaning what?”

“Well, you found the Commonwealth War Graves reference to Stuart, didn’t you? And we have a death certificate for Thomas. I’m not too worried about Philip - his death was quite recent, and even Laurel should have got that right.”

Danny noticed what might have been a brief sneer crossing Harry’s lips, but it disappeared as quickly as it came. He wondered whether Harry was being too hard on Laurel: not everyone was as obsessed by genealogy as he was, after all. Everyone made mistakes when it came to family history, just as in life itself. And if anyone should know that, then surely it was Harry McFry?